Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

plenty of people do try to learn a second language. that's why apps like duolingo are popular. but language is a medium for exchange, and if you have no one to practice with i don't think you'll really get it. of course, i only speak english myself.

you would really trust yourself to translate a film after picking up a language without ever speaking it with anyone?



> you would really trust yourself to translate a film after picking up a language without ever speaking it with anyone?

Sure, this is completely normal. For example, coastal Albanians tend to understand Italian films, television and radio quite well just from exposure to Italian-language broadcasting, even if they never actually interact with Italians. And as I mentioned elsewhere, for a lot of people who learn to understand Spanish media, it all happens through telenovelas, not time spent with actual Latin American people.

Over the last year, I have been studying Serbian and Albanian without much interaction at all with speakers, and I am already at the point where I can enjoy many films and television programmes – sure, I might have to occasionally pause the video and rewind it or look up a word in the dictionary, but the learning and reference materials I have at my disposal are completely sufficient for that, there is no need to actually speak with anyone.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: